Tinbergen's Four Questions - Four Categories of Questions and Explanations - Evolutionary (ultimate) Explanations - 2 Phylogeny (evolution)

2 Phylogeny (evolution)

Phylogeny captures all evolutionary explanations other than function/adaptation. There are several reasons why natural selection may fail to achieve optimal design (Mayr 2001:140–143; Buss et al. 1998). One entails random processes such as mutation and environmental events acting on small populations. Another entails the constraints resulting from early evolutionary development. Each organism harbors traits, both anatomical and behavioral, of previous phylogenetic stages, since many traits are retained as species evolve. Reconstructing the phylogeny of a species often makes it possible to understand the "uniqueness" of recent characteristics: Earlier phylogenetic stages and (pre-) conditions which persist often also determine the form of more modern characteristics. For instance, the vertebrate eye (including the human eye) has a blind spot, whereas octopus eyes do not. In those two lineages, the eye was originally constructed one way or the other. Once the vertebrate eye was constructed, there were no intermediate forms that were both adaptive and would have enabled it to evolve without a blind spot.

Read more about this topic:  Tinbergen's Four Questions, Four Categories of Questions and Explanations, Evolutionary (ultimate) Explanations