1800–1900
- 1800: William Haycock of Owston in Leicestershire
- 1801: William Kemp of Belton
- 1802: William Gillson of Burleigh
- 1804: Cotton Thompson of Ketton
- 1805: John Hack of Clipsham
- 1806: John Hotchkin of Tixover
- 1807: William Shield of Wing
- 1808: Thomas Bryan of Stoke
- 1809: Abel Walford Bellears of Bulmerthorpe
- 1810: William Gillson of Wing
- 1811: The Hon George Watson, of Rockingham Castle
- 1812: Sir Gerard Noel, 2nd Baronet, of Exton Park
- 1813: Stafford O'Brien
- 1814: George Fludyer of Ayston
- 1815: Samuel Parker or Barker, of Lyndon
- 1816: John Cole Gilson of Berley
- 1817: Thomas Faulkner Baines, of Morcott
- 1818: Robert Peach of Lyddington
- 1819: James Tiptaft of Braunston
- 1820: Robert Sheild of Wing
- 1821: William Lawrence of Preston
- 1822: Thomas Floar of Whissendine
- 1823: Thomas Thompson of Tinwell
- 1824: John Morris of North Luffenham
- 1825: John Neal of Belton
- 1826: Thomas Hill of Uppingham
- 1827: Thomas John Bryan of Stoke Dry
- 1828: Thomas Walker of Liddington
- 1829: George Finch of Burley
- 1830: John Eagleton, of South Luffenham
- 1831: Thomas Birch Reynardson, of Essendine
- 1832: William Gilford of North Luffenham
- 1833: John Muxloe Wingfield of Market Overton
- 1834: Edward Watson Smyth of Gunthorpe
- 1835: Godfrey Kemp of Belton
- 1836: Richard Wade of Uppingham
- 1837: John Stokes of Caldecott
- 1838: Matthew Laxton of Greetham
- 1839: John Monkton of Seaton
- 1840: Samuel Richard Fydell of Morcott
- 1841: Joseph Tomblin of Leighfield
- 1842: Richard Westbrook Baker of Cottesmore
- 1843: George Fludyer of Ayston
- 1844: Charles Grantham of Ketton
- 1845: Henry Bennet Pierrepont of Ryhall
- 1846: John Gilson of Wing
- 1847: Richard Lucas of Edith Weston
- 1848: Hon. Charles George Noel, Viscount Campden of Flitteriss_Park
- 1849: John Thomas Springthorpe of Manton
- 1850: Hon. William Middleton Noel of Ketton
- 1851: John Moore Paget of Clipsham
- 1852: William de Capell Brooke of Martinsthorpe
- 1853: John Parker of Preston
- 1854: Robert Lee Bradshaw of Tinwell
- 1855: Arthur Heathcoate of Pilton
- 1856: Clarke Morris of Oakham
- 1857: Ayscough Smith of Braunston
- 1858: William Rudkin Morris of North Luffenham
- 1859: Edward Henry Cradock Monckton, of Seaton
- 1860: Samuel Hunt of Ketton
- 1861: William Fludyer of Ayston
- 1862: William Evans-Freke, 8th Baron Carbery
- 1863: Hon. Henry Lewis Noel of Exton Park
- 1864: Charles Ormston Eaton of Tixover
- 1865: William Gilford of North Luffenham
- 1866: William Wing
- 1867: Edward Nathaniel Conant of Lyndon
- 1868: Robert Heathcote of North Luffenham
- 1869: Richard Septimus Wilkinson of Manton
- 1870: George Dawson Rowley, of Morcott
- 1871: John Harry Lee Wingfield
- 1872: Charles Cave John Orme of Oakham
- 1873: Francis Heathcote of Pilton
- 1874: Thomas John Stafford Hotchkin of South Luffenham
- 1875: William Belgrave of Preston
- 1876: Edward Frewen of Braunston
- 1877: John Turner Hopwood, of Ketton
- 1878: George Gerard Charles Fenwick of Morcott
- 1879: Edward Sharrard Calcraft Kennedy of Whissendine
- 1880: Westley Richards of Ashwell
- 1881: The Hon Francis Pierremont Cecil of Stocken Hall on active naval service and replaced April 1881 by Richard Tryon of Oakham
- 1882: John William Handley Davenport-Handley of Clipsham
- 1883: Edward Philip Monckton
- 1884: William Gore Marshall of Hambleton
- 1885: William Cunliffe Gosling of Oakham
- 1886: Frederick Gordon Blair of Ashwell
- 1887: Arthur Morrice Blake of Whissendine
- 1888: Robert Neill of Wing
- 1889: Blake Alexander Hankey of Essendine, Stamford
- 1890: Edward Worrall of Wing Oakham,
- 1891: George Fydell Rowley of Morcott, Uppingham
- 1892: Evan Hanbury of Braunston, Oakham
- 1893: Francis John Berry of Wing, Oakham
- 1894: William Baird of Oakham
- 1895: Colonel Charles Birch Reynardson of Essendine, Stamford
- 1896: George Whyatt Worrall of Wing, Oakham
- 1897: Henry Clarke Jervoise of Langham
- 1898: The Honourable William Charles Wentworth Fitzwilliam, of Barnsdale, near Oakham.
- 1899: Arthur Richard de Capell Brooke 1st and last Baron Brooke of Oakley
Read more about this topic: High Sheriff Of Rutland