The Edwin Mellen Press is a Lewiston, New York-based publishing house founded by religion scholar Herbert Richardson. It describes itself as "a non-subsidy academic publisher of books in the humanities and social science", but has been described by others as a vanity press.
The Press has received criticism for taking legal action against its critics. In 1993 it brought a libel suit against the magazine Lingua Franca, which it lost. In 2012 it brought a similar suit for $3.5 million against McMaster University and a librarian hired there in 2011 over a blog posting he made in 2010. This suit has been criticized by the Canadian Association of University Teachers and others as an attempt to use legal action to silence criticism whose publication is an exercise of academic freedom. Created by Martha Reineke, a professor of religion at the University of Northern Iowa, a petition demanding the Press drop its lawsuits had garnered more than 3,100 names as of March 4, 2013. On that date, the Press announced that it had discontinued the court case against McMaster University and Dale Askey, but not the lawsuit against Askey personally.
On March 21, 2013, Edwin Mellen Press threatened legal action against The Scholarly Kitchen for hosting allegedly libelous blog posts and comments. The Scholarly Kitchen removed the content in question from its website on March 29, 2013. It restored the blog post, though not the comment alleged to be libellous, a few days later, and published a blog post explaining its actions. In April 2013, the Press threatened to take legal action against the interim library dean of the University of Utah, over blog posts he wrote criticising the Press for its legal action against Askey.
Earlier aspects of this controversy have been studied by sociologist Kenneth Westhues in his book The Envy of Excellence: Administrative Mobbing of High Achieving Professors, a title published by the Edwin Mellen Press.
Dr. Richardson had been in possession of the lost diary of Hitler aide Alfred Rosenberg, finally turned over to federal agents in April, 2013, for return to a collection now owned by the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum.
Famous quotes containing the words edwin, mellen and/or press:
“Conscience was the barmaid of the Victorian soul. Recognizing that human beings were fallible and that their failings, though regrettable, must be humoured, conscience would permit, rather ungraciously perhaps, the indulgence of a number of carefully selected desires.”
—C.E.M. (Cyril Edwin Mitchinson)
“He’s a comer. That’s what comers do: they get in your face.”
—Michael Tolkin, U.S. screenwriter, and Robert Altman. Dick Mellen (Sydney Pollack)
“Oh! snatch’d away in beauty’s bloom,
On thee shall press no ponderous tomb;
But on thy turf shall roses rear
Their leaves, the earliest of the year;”
—George Gordon Noel Byron (1788–1824)