1400–1500
- 1400: John Pensax
- 1401: Roland Senliz or Sinluce
- 1402: John Arblaster
- 1404: Thomas Thorpe
- 1405: John Basynges
- 1405: John Daneys ( probably acted till Michaelmas 1407)
- 1407: Roger Flore
- 1408: Thomas Oudeby
- 1409: John Clerk
- 1410: William Greneham
- 1411: Thomas Corby
- 1411: Sir Thomas Burton, Kt
- 1411: Thomas Corby
- 1412: Roger Flore
- 1413: Thomas Onderly
- 1415: James Bellers
- 1416: John Boyvill
- 1416: Sir Thomas Burton, Kt. (son of Thomas, HS 1379)
- 1417: Robert Brown
- 1418: Robert Chisleden
- 1419: John Pensax
- 1420: James Bellers (died 1421)
- 1421: Sir Thomas Burton, Kt. (2nd term)
- 1422: Sir Thomas Burton, Kt. (3rd term)
- 1424: John Onderby
- 1425: John Davies
- 1426: John Colepeper
- 1427: Henry Plessington
- 1428: Sir Thomas Burton, Kt. (4th term)
- 1429: John Denys
- 1430: John Colepeper
- 1431: Thomas Flore (1st term)
- 1432: Henry Plessington
- 1433: John Boyvill
- 1434: William Beaufo
- 1435: Robert Davies and John Pilton
- 1436: John Branspath
- 1437: Hugo Boyvill
- 1438: Laurence Sherard
- 1439: William Beaufo
- 1440: Thomas Burton (son of 1417)
- 1441: Henry Plessington
- 1442: Thomas Flore (2nd term)
- 1443: William Beaufo
- 1444: Thomas Barkeley
- 1445: John Basings
- 1446: William Walker
- 1447: John Boyvill
- 1448: William Haseldon
- 1449: Hugo Boyvill
- 1450: Robert Fenne
- 1451: Thomas Flore (3rd term)
- 1452: William Heton
- 1453: Robert Sherard
- 1454: Robert Fenne
- 1455: William Beaufo
- 1456: William Haselden
- 1457: Thomas Flore (4th term)
- 1458: Thomas Dale
- 1459: Robert Fenne
- 1460: Everard Digby
- 1461: John Francis
- 1462–1463: Thomas Palmer
- 1464: William Greenham
- 1465: Thomas Flore (5th term)
- 1466: Richard Sopcotts
- 1467: William Browne
- 1468: Geoffrey Sherard
- 1469: John Dale
- 1470: Thomas Flore (6th term)
- 1471: Brian Talbot
- 1472: Thomas Berkeley
- 1473: William Haselden
- 1474: John Pilton
- 1475: William Browne
- 1476: John Sapcote
- 1477: David Malpas
- 1478: Henry Mackworth
- 1479: John Pilton
- 1480: Geoffrey Sherard
- 1481: William Palmer
- 1482: David Malpas
- 1483: William Browne
- 1484: Geoffrey Sherard
- 1485: John Pilton
- 1486: Everard Digby
- 1487: William Browne
- 1488: David Malpas
- 1489: Maurice Berkley
- 1490: Thomas Sapcotes
- 1491: John Digby
- 1492: Robert Harrington of Redlington
- 1493: Christopher Browne
- 1494: John Pilton
- 1495: Thomas Sherard
- 1496: Thomas Sapcots
- 1497: George Mackworth
- 1498: Robert Harrington of Redlington
- 1499: Everard Digby
Read more about this topic: High Sheriff Of Rutland