Left Realist Criminology emerged out of Critical Criminology as a reaction against what was perceived to be the Left's failure to take a practical interest in everyday crime, leaving it to the Right Realists to monopolize the political agenda on law and order. Left Realism argues that crime disproportionately affects working class people, but that solutions that only increase repression serve to make the crime problem worse. Instead they argue that the root causes of crime lie in relative deprivation, although preventative measures and policing are necessary, but these should be democratically controlled.
Pat Carlen (1992) suggests that the main tenets of left realism are:
- 'The basic triangle of relations which is the proper subject-matter of criminology - the offender, the state and the victim' (Young, 1986) (since altered to include society at large, see The Square of Crime)
- Theoretical explanations must be symmetrical - there must be the same explanation for social action and reaction.
- 'Man is a creator of human nature' (Young, 1987), and therefore explanations of crime should not be deterministic and people should be seen as being responsible for their actions.
- Crime is a real problem and especially to working-class people who suffer disproportionately from personal crime, such as robbery, assault, burglary and rape.
- The 'left' should attempt to develop a credible (populist?) approach to crime control in order to prevent the 'right' from having a monopoly of the 'crime problem'.
- The purpose of theorizing should be to make practical interventions into law and order issues.
- In order to reduce crime there is a need to achieve a higher level of cooperation between police and public, and this will be best achieved by a democratization of local control of the police."
Other articles related to "left realism, realism, left":
... Criminologists such as Roger Hopkins Burke see left realism as 'very influential with the 'New' Labour Government elected in 1997' suggesting that acts such as the 1998 Crime and Disorder Act ...
... (1991) "Left Realism and the Priorities of Crime Control" In Stenson, K ... (1992) "Ten Points of Realism" Matthews, R ... (1992) "Questioning Left Realism" Young, J ...
... and Ronald Osborn at the University of Southern California, have argued for the idea of a “Left Realism” in IR theory with particular reference to the work of Noam Chomsky ... the analytical assumptions of classical realism combined with a radical moral, normative or "Left" critique of the state ...
Famous quotes containing the words realism and/or left:
“The realism of failure, the romance of success.”
—Mason Cooley (b. 1927)
“The more important the title, the more self-important the person, the greater the amount of time spent on the Eastern shuttle, the more suspicious the man and the less vitality in the organization.”
—Jane OReilly, U.S. feminist and humorist. The Girl I Left Behind, ch. 5 (1980)