WGA Screenwriting Credit System - Arbitration


Some Guild members have criticized the arbitration process. The Guild, however, have won most lawsuits against them, and in 2002 the WGA membership overwhelmingly rejected changes to the arbitration procedures.

A chief objection is the secrecy of the process. Identities of the arbiters are secret, so concerned parties have no way to object to the qualifications or possible biases of their judges. Also, any explanation of the decision itself is secret, even from the parties to the dispute, so they have no way to know why they lost or won credit. Secret rationales make an appeal impossible, and define no precedent for future disputes. There is an appeal panel, but it only concerns itself with technical details as to whether the decision followed the rules.

Guild members have criticized the way the process handles existing material, such as a book, that is adapted to film. Generally, the first writer to work on such a project naturally appropriates the most cinematic elements of the story. Other teams that subsequently work on the script, however, may base their work on the original text rather than that first draft. Barry Levinson, the director of Wag the Dog and a disputant over screenwriting credit for the film (which was adapted from a novel), says:

If a writer creates an idea from scratch, that's one thing. Even if the script is given to other writers and rewritten, that first writer created the seeds of that idea and he or she should get some regard. But for a script from a book, it's different.

Even if little of the initial efforts remain in the final script, the original writer is often awarded credit because he or she was first on the scene.

Read more about this topic:  WGA Screenwriting Credit System

Other articles related to "arbitration":

Arbitration Roundtable Of Toronto - Arbitration
... Arbitration focuses on resolving conflicts outside of courthouse litigation ... Parties defer to one or more mutually acceptable arbitrators who will come to the final decision ...
Arbitration - Nomenclature
... As methods of dispute resolution, arbitration procedure can be varied to suit the needs of the parties ... Certain specific "types" of arbitration procedure have developed, particularly in North America ... Judicial Arbitration is, usually, not arbitration at all, but merely a court process which refers to itself as arbitration, such as small claims arbitration before the ...
Arbitration Roundtable Of Toronto - Associations
... Members of The Arbitration Roundtable of Toronto are associated with international groups promoting arbitration including ADR Chambers, The ...
Conciliation And Arbitration Act 1904
... The Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904 was an Australian Commonwealth Government Act "relating to Conciliation and Arbitration for the Prevention and Settlement of ... disputes To constitute a Commonwealth Court of Conciliation and Arbitration having jurisdiction for the prevention and settlement of industrial disputes To provide for the exercise of the jurisdiction of the ... the Commonwealth Court of Conciliation and Arbitration ...
Court Of Arbitration (New South Wales) - Background
... This Act provided the first legislated non-common law arbitration scheme for disputes between employers and employees ... of both employer and employee to engage in conciliation or arbitration ... However, a declining labour market meant that employers were not prepared to accept arbitration and Patmore reports that only two of twenty two cases under that law were settled ...