Opinion of The Court
The Court held that, since the Appeal Board gave no reason for the denial of a conscientious objector exemption to petitioner, and it is impossible to determine on which of the three grounds offered in the Justice Department's letter that board relied, Ali's conviction must be reversed.
Bob Woodward and Scott Armstrong provide an account of the development of the decision in their book The Brethren. According to that account, Justice Marshall had recused himself because he had been U.S. Solicitor General when the case began, and the remaining eight justices initially voted 5 to 3 to uphold Ali's conviction. However, Justice Harlan, assigned to write the majority opinion, became convinced that Ali's claim to be a conscientious objector was sincere after reading background material on Black Muslim doctrine provided by one of his law clerks. To the contrary, Justice Harlan concluded that the claim by the Justice Department had been a misrepresentation. Harlan changed his vote, tying the vote at 4 to 4. A deadlock would have resulted in Ali being jailed for draft evasion and, since no opinions are published for deadlocked decisions, he would have never known why he had lost. A compromise proposed by Justice Stewart, in which Ali's conviction would be reversed citing a technical error by the Justice Department, gradually won unanimous assent from the eight voting justices.
Read more about this topic: Clay V. United States
Other articles related to "opinion of the court, court, opinion, the court":
... The Supreme Court recognized that a conflict existed between the demands of contract law, which “forbids a purchaser to repudiate his promises simply because he later becomes dissatisfied with ...
... The opinion was authored by Justice Souter, who wrote "We hold that one who distributes a device with the object of promoting its use to infringe copyright, as shown by clear expression or ... While the Court unanimously concurred that Grokster could be liable for inducing copyright infringement, there was considerable disagreement over whether the case is substantially different from the Sony ... The Souter opinion does not address whether or not Sony protects Grokster ...
... Lee, the court held that “evidence discovered, directly or indirectly, as a result of a constitutional violation must be suppressed" under the ... Expanding the subscriber rights established in the Wiretap Act, the court held that a subscriber whose records had been wrongfully obtained has the right to bring a motion to suppress ... Though the court held that the suppression of the evidence would be fatal to the indictment in its current form, it found that the State could go forward by moving to dismiss the indictment ...
Famous quotes containing the words opinion of, court and/or opinion:
“To whom, then, must I dedicate my wonderful, surprising and interesting adventures?to whom dare I reveal my private opinion of my nearest relations? the secret thoughts of my dearest friends? my own hopes, fears, reflections and dislikes?Nobody!”
—Frances Burney (17521840)
“World history is a court of judgment.”
—Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel (17701831)
“There are certain times when public opinion is the worst of all opinions.”
—Sébastien-Roch Nicolas De Chamfort (17411794)